Thornton provided THFB with this assessment of McAvoy:
"Charlie reminds me of a young [Washington Caps D] John Carlson that played for me with the Rockets’ junior program back in 2005-06, a true pro prospect due to his size and stature on the ice. He is an offensive right shot defenseman who flourished playing in our junior program as well as our independent midget U18 schedule, totaling a combined 89 games played last season. Charlie played with and against players 2-3 years older than him, which allowed him to progress faster due to the role he was used. He logged the most minutes of any defenseman we had and played in all situations with his strength being the power play. All of his success helped our Jr. B team to win it second Keegan Cup in a row and he won MJHL Offensive defenseman of the year."
Scouted on July 7-13, 2013 @ USA Select 16 FestivalMcAvoy was a stud on the blueline. He is a very smart defender with a lot of size and grit. He has excellent feet and was easily the top rearguard on his team and maybe in this Festival. He pinches well and holds the blueline with authority, an absolute beast on the ice. He has a bomb for a shot and looks to inflict pain and finish every single check. He has become an NHL prospect and is well on his way to hearing his name early in 2016. AHR Rating: AAAScouted on July 9, 2013 @ USA Select 16 FestivalMcAvoy is a high end talent who showed a great all-around game. He has very good size and uses it to lay some great hits. He sees the ice very well and creates plays for his team from the back end. His skill level is high end and he pinches very well. He likes to move the puck and is a beast in his own end. As a late birth year player he will for sure move up the ranks of NHL draft lists in the coming years. AHR Rating: A
Charles McAvoy, D, ’97 (NJ Rockets-MET) — Is a 12/21/97 birth date, meaning he is almost a ’98. Played last season for the Long Island Gulls U14 team and along with Jeremy Bracco, Nolan Aibel and Troy Conzo made the move to the Rockets. McAvoy may fly under the radar a bit, but the more you pay attention to him the more you like him. He’s a strong skater, and confident with the puck.